Who Gets to Become Senior Counsel?
The Recommendation Panel Under Scrutiny: Merit, Sponsorship and Fairness
Qs & As
By LEX
The Senior Counsel and Senior Attorney Act 2025 was meant to turn the page on a controversial appointment process by replacing individual discretion with a more transparent, collective and merit-based system. Yet, barely a year later, a fresh controversy has emerged. The Recommendation Panel’s introduction of a mandatory sponsorship requirement for applicants has triggered strong objections within the legal profession, raising questions about equal access, procedural fairness and the limits of the Panel’s authority. Has a reform designed to open up the process inadvertently created a new barrier to entry? We examine the legal, institutional and political implications of this controversy.
* The Senior Counsel and Senior Attorney Act 2025 was hastily passed in October 2025 to resolve a judicial review crisis over controversial appointments made in August 2025. However, one year later, a new crisis has emerged — shifting from who was appointed to who is allowed to apply, with applicants now required as a first step to secure formal sponsorship from existing Senior Counsels (SC) or Senior Attorneys (SA). What is your take on that?
The introduction of an obligatory sponsorship mechanism by the newly formed Recommendation Panel has effectively replaced an opaque appointment process. While the Senior Counsel and Senior Attorney Act 2025 was designed to codify meritocracy, remove political arbitrariness, and satisfy the bar, the current crisis highlights how procedural reforms can inadvertently create new hurdles and complications.
* Given that both the Bar Council and the Law Society are represented on the Recommendation Panel, how did a rule provoking such widespread backlash across the profession get adopted in the first place. Did it truly have the Panel’s consensus?
Views within the legal profession and across the panel were far from unanimous. Although statutory representation guarantees the Bar Council and Law Society a seat at the table, a simple majority voting system allows decisions to be pushed through over the objections of the practicing bar’s representatives.
* Is there a loophole in the law that allowed the Recommendation Panel to introduce the controversial sponsorship requirement?
The Recommendation Panel did not exploit a hidden “loophole” per se; rather, it relied on a broad discretionary provision in the Senior Counsel and Senior Attorney Act 2025 — specifically Section 4(10) — alongside the statute’s silence on a formal application procedure. Although the legislation set out the overarching framework, the 15-year minimum seniority requirement, and the composition of the seven-member panel, it left the panel with the structural autonomy to regulate its own internal proceedings.
The resulting mandatory sponsorship (parrainage) rules — requiring endorsements from two Senior Counsel (SC) and two Senior Attorneys (SA), capped at three candidates per sponsor — have drawn strong pushback from the Mauritius Bar Association (MBA) due to the scarcity of available senior barristers and attorneys.
* Me Jacques Tsang Mang Kin, Me Ammanah Ragavoodoo, and Me Avinash Renga Sunassee challenged the controversial August 2025 appointments via judicial review and only withdrew their case in October 2025 on the understanding that the new Act would guarantee fairness and transparency. Does the new sponsorship rule — which Parliament never intended — betray the spirit of the October 2025 legislative compromise and risk exposing the process to a fresh round of judicial reviews?
The Bar Council and members of the legal profession argue that the restrictive sponsorship requirements, particularly in view of the limited pool of eligible sponsors (including the relatively small number of Senior Attorneys) and the cap of three candidates per sponsor, risk creating a closed and exclusive system. They contend that this could not have been Parliament’s intention when it enacted the legislation.
The central concern is that rules intended to regulate the appointment process may, in practice, restrict access to it, creating a system in which opportunities depend largely on the availability and willingness of a limited number of sponsors.
*The core legal issue concerns the limits of the Panel’s procedural autonomy: can a statutory body established to ensure transparency and merit-based selection lawfully introduce mandatory sponsorship as a preliminary barrier when this requirement is not expressly provided for in the Senior Counsel and Senior Attorney Act 2025?
Section 3 of the Act sets out the eligibility requirements, including 15 years’ standing on the Roll. The Panel’s decision to make sponsorship compulsory could therefore be challenged as introducing an additional eligibility condition beyond those laid down by Parliament. A statutory body’s procedural autonomy cannot, in principle, extend to altering substantive eligibility criteria established by legislation.
The 2025 Act was intended to replace an opaque and largely unilateral selection process with a more transparent, objective and merit-based system. Yet, with reportedly only 25 practising Senior Attorneys available to act as sponsors, and strict limits on the number of candidates each can endorse, the requirement risks creating a bottleneck that restricts equal access to the selection process.
More fundamentally, it introduces a pre-selection filter before the Recommendation Panel even considers an application. In effect, an initial screening power shifts from the statutory Panel to individual Senior Counsels and Senior Attorneys. Faced with a limit on the number of candidates they can sponsor, these senior practitioners must choose whom to endorse. Consequently, otherwise qualified candidates could be excluded, not because they lack merit or fail to meet the statutory requirements, but simply because they cannot secure a sponsor or because a potential sponsor has already reached the endorsement limit.
It seems to me that this arrangement risks undermining the very principles of equal opportunity, transparency and merit-based selection that the legislation was intended to uphold.
* When introducing and defending the Senior Counsel and Senior Attorney Bill in Parliament in October 2025, Me Gavin Glover emphasized that the reform was specifically designed to replace the sole discretionary power of the Chief Justice under the old legal framework with a collegial system grounded in merit, integrity, clarity, and transparency. That sounds fair, so the question that arises is: what could have been the reasons for introducing the sponsorship requirement into the appointment process?
The sponsorship (parrainage) requirement was not expressly provided for in the Senior Counsel and Senior Attorney Act 2025. It was introduced instead by the newly established Recommendation Panel through the official application forms and guidelines issued in November 2026.
The requirement appears intended to serve as a preliminary screening mechanism. With the transition from a largely opaque appointment process to an open, merit-based application system, the Panel may have anticipated a substantial number of applications from practitioners meeting the minimum requirement of 15 years’ standing on the Roll. Sponsorship could therefore be seen as an attempt to assess candidates’ professional standing and reputation among their peers, while preserving the prestige associated with the honorary distinction of silk.
However, this approach has generated controversy within the Mauritius Bar Association, particularly over whether sponsorship is an appropriate means of assessing merit and whether it risks restricting access to the selection process.
While preliminary screening mechanisms may be justified on administrative grounds, they must be balanced against the principles of procedural fairness and equal opportunity. Excluding highly qualified candidates through structural barriers risks creating an injustice. Practitioners who meet the statutory eligibility requirements and have more than 15 years of professional experience could nevertheless encounter an invisible ceiling if their progression depends on securing sponsorship and personal connections rather than being assessed on objective merit.
* With the application deadline set for November 30, 2026, the burden now falls on the Recommendation Panel to decide whether to amend their internal procedures in response to the Bar’s proposals. This issue will hopefully be resolved. What options are available to the Bar and the Executive if the Recommendation Panel refuses to reconsider its position before the deadline?
If the Recommendation Panel, chaired by Chief Justice Rehana Mungly-Gulbul, refuses to amend its internal procedures concerning the restrictive sponsorship requirements before the November 30, 2026, deadline, the Mauritius Bar Association (MBA) and the Executive branch have several legal and strategic options available.
Although the Senior Counsel and Senior Attorney Act 2025 grants the Recommendation Panel autonomy to regulate its own procedures, this does not necessarily place its decisions beyond judicial scrutiny. The Bar could therefore consider seeking judicial review (recours en révision judiciaire) before the Supreme Court. Affected practitioners, or potentially the MBA, could challenge the sponsorship requirements on the grounds that the restrictive quotas on the number of candidates each Senior Counsel or Senior Attorney may sponsor unfairly limit access to the selection process for otherwise eligible candidates. They could also seek urgent interim relief to prevent the November 30 deadline from expiring while the legal challenge is being considered.
Ultimately, the Bar Council could formally advise its members, particularly existing Senior Counsels and Senior Attorneys, to consider collectively withholding sponsorship or encourage eligible practitioners not to apply under the contested rules, thereby challenging the legitimacy of the current exercise.
*Critics argue that the Recommendation Panel, despite being chaired by the Chief Justice, is acting in an administrative capacity and cannot use its procedural autonomy to introduce or restrict eligibility criteria that fall within Parliament’s legislative authority. What is your view on this argument?
The controversy surrounding the Panel’s reliance on procedural autonomy to determine eligibility raises a fundamental constitutional question. It brings into focus the tension between the practical need for administrative screening and the principle of parliamentary sovereignty, under which only Parliament has the authority to establish statutory eligibility requirements.
*At the end of the day, there is a nagging feeling that this controversy may involve more than just eligibility criteria and procedural rules. Following the political tensions surrounding the August 2025 appointments, could politics still be playing an unseen role in the introduction of these new barriers?
Whenever new eligibility criteria and procedural requirements are introduced into an appointment process, tensions can arise between administrative necessity and political considerations. Whether these new procedures represent a genuine effort to improve transparency and governance or are influenced by other calculations will ultimately depend on their rationale, how they are applied and whether they are seen to serve the interests of fairness and merit.
Mauritius Times ePaper Friday 13 November 2026
An Appeal
Dear Reader
65 years ago Mauritius Times was founded with a resolve to fight for justice and fairness and the advancement of the public good. It has never deviated from this principle no matter how daunting the challenges and how costly the price it has had to pay at different times of our history.
With print journalism struggling to keep afloat due to falling advertising revenues and the wide availability of free sources of information, it is crucially important for the Mauritius Times to survive and prosper. We can only continue doing it with the support of our readers.
The best way you can support our efforts is to take a subscription or by making a recurring donation through a Standing Order to our non-profit Foundation.
Thank you.
Related Posts
-
SM Malleck Amode
No Comments | Mar 11, 2010 -
Mauritius welcomes Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath
No Comments | Nov 10, 2017 -
The Socio-Culturals
No Comments | Aug 25, 2017 -
“The FCC: Same old vinegar in a new bottle, but with a political appointee shielded from accountability”
No Comments | Dec 8, 2023
