Chagos: A Diplomatic Opening, But No Room for Complacency
International Relations
The latest exchanges with London open a route to a structured Mauritius-UK-US process on Diego Garcia. The Greenland agreement offers a procedural cue; the task now is to turn the year-end commitment into measurable progress.
The meeting between Prime Minister Navin Ramgoolam and his British counterpart, Andy Burnham, on the margins of the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting in Antigua has reopened a political channel that had been allowed to narrow. The two leaders agreed to work on a shared plan to make further progress on Chagos by the end of the year. The official UK Government readout stated that Burnham had underlined his commitment to working with Mauritius and the United States on a way forward that would secure Diego Garcia’s operation and protect the national security of all three countries.
BIOT Court of Appeal underscores full Mauritian sovereignty over Chagos
The British Indian Ocean Territory (BIOT) Court of Appeal handed down its judgment in the Misley Mandarin case yesterday. Crucially, the ruling opens by affirming that the 2025 Treaty recognises Mauritius’s sovereignty over the Chagos Archipelago in its entirety, including Diego Garcia. The Court further notes that the implementing legislation has completed its passage through both Houses of the UK Parliament and now awaits Royal Assent. It is strictly within this settled legal framework that current discussions must proceed — focused on implementing the agreement, not reopening the question of sovereignty.
That is welcome. The UK Government readout says the leaders agreed to work on a shared plan to make further progress by the end of the year; the Mauritian account records Ramgoolam’s request for a clear roadmap with an initial milestone in December. This sets a concrete next step, although neither statement promises ratification or a final settlement by December. Mauritius must ensure that the shared plan identifies measurable steps and does not become another period of waiting.
Burnham’s subsequent remarks to The Economist are significant. He referred to the recent United States-Denmark-Greenland agreement as a possible source of ideas for resolving the impasse over Diego Garcia. That reference appears to recognise the practical case for bringing the relevant parties together. It does not mean that Burnham has formally accepted former Deputy Prime Minister Paul Bérenger’s proposal for a high-level Mauritius-UK-US meeting. But his language creates a clear opening for Port Louis to put that proposal on the table.

Mauritius should put the proposal on the table without delay. A meeting at political level, followed by a tripartite working group, would let the three governments address security concerns directly, identify the assurances and practical arrangements required for the base, and set milestones towards implementing the agreement signed on 22 May 2025. The December milestone should specify what can be agreed, who is responsible, and what follows next.
The Greenland experience offers a procedural cue, not a comparison between the two cases. Greenland is an autonomous territory within the Kingdom of Denmark, and its security agreement with the United States preserves Danish sovereignty and recognises Greenlanders’ right to self-determination. Chagos has a different history and legal foundation. Mauritius’s sovereignty over the archipelago, including Diego Garcia, has been recognised in the agreement signed with the United Kingdom. That sovereignty is not a subject for reopening.
What Mauritius can take from the Greenland process is the value of a structured channel in which security questions are addressed by all the parties concerned, rather than exchanged through public statements or treated as grounds for indefinite delay. Any tripartite mechanism must begin from the agreement already reached. Its purpose would be to settle the practical questions that have impeded ratification and to provide a credible route towards implementation — not to renegotiate the sovereignty of Mauritius or dilute the treaty under another name.
This distinction matters. Mauritius has never denied the strategic importance of Diego Garcia or the security interests of the United States and the United Kingdom. But security must be addressed within a framework that respects the agreed transfer of sovereignty. A process without terms of reference, deadlines and political ownership could simply prolong the present uncertainty. Mauritius should be ready to negotiate constructively, while making clear that patience cannot be mistaken for consent to drift.
There is also a separate Commonwealth dimension to the Prime Minister’s participation in Antigua. During the leaders’ retreat, Ramgoolam firmly objected to the proposal that the Maldives host the next Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (CHOGM). His objection was grounded in the Maldives’ position on Chagos and its claims concerning the archipelago. A Commonwealth summit is not simply a venue allocated by rotation. It is an occasion on which member states affirm the principles of the Commonwealth Charter, including respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity.
This is not a personal or bilateral quarrel. A country that contests Mauritius’s sovereignty should expect its position to be challenged when it seeks the visible responsibility of hosting Commonwealth leaders. Mauritius is right to state its opposition plainly and insist that the Commonwealth’s principles apply consistently to every member.
The Antigua meeting has thus produced both an opening and a test. The opening is a commitment by London to work with Port Louis and Washington on a shared plan before the end of the year. The test is whether that commitment can be translated into a structured process with a defined destination. Mauritius should seize the moment and propose the high-level tripartite meeting, using the Greenland arrangement as a practical cue while remaining entirely clear about the difference between the two cases.
The country has pursued its claim through law and diplomacy with persistence. It should now carry that same purpose into the next phase — that is, engage London and Washington at the highest level, secure an agreed timetable, and defend its position wherever it is challenged. A diplomatic opening is valuable. It becomes meaningful only when it leads to action.
9 November 2026
Mauritius Times ePaper Friday 13 November 2026
An Appeal
Dear Reader
65 years ago Mauritius Times was founded with a resolve to fight for justice and fairness and the advancement of the public good. It has never deviated from this principle no matter how daunting the challenges and how costly the price it has had to pay at different times of our history.
With print journalism struggling to keep afloat due to falling advertising revenues and the wide availability of free sources of information, it is crucially important for the Mauritius Times to survive and prosper. We can only continue doing it with the support of our readers.
The best way you can support our efforts is to take a subscription or by making a recurring donation through a Standing Order to our non-profit Foundation.
Thank you.
